A Law & Economic Analysis Of 'Ordinance Raj' In India: Navigating The Rule V Standard Debate In The Legal Design As A Mechanism To Reduce Political Cartelization
The data available for the promulgation of the ordinances clearly shows that the number ofordinances that have been enacted post the judgement in the Krishna Kumar Case is in nosense less than the ordinances that have been enacted during the years preceding the judgment.This is so despite the negative impact of the Krishna Kumar judgement on the utility that theexecutive ought to derive from the enactment of the ordinances. The authors seek to addressthis anomaly through the microeconomic models and present solutions through the lens of lawand economics. This paper conceptualises the solution to the problem of the misuse and theabuse of ordinancemaking power by proposing the formulation of the rules that shall seek toadd objective grounds to test if the ordinancemaking power has been used in a proper manneror it has been used with the mala fide intentions and illwill on the part of the executive. Thelevel of the delegation to the executive, that is, the scope of the decisionmaking with the,executive, has been analysed by proposing the total cost curve, which seeks to propose theoptimum level of stringency in the rules so as to allow the scope for the legislature to meet theemergency situations as well. This is sought to be achieved by framing of such rules for theexercise of the ordinancemaking power by the president and the governor, in such a way as tohave the objective grounds for the test of the need for the ordinancemaking power and also atthe same time have the scope and leeway to the legislature to decide, if the matter needs theenactment of the ordinance to meet the emergency that has arisen.
However, in certain emergency situations, this power to enact primary legislations has also been entrusted with the executive head of the state, i.e. the President, who under Article 123 of the Indian Constitution, may pass an ordinance which shall have the same effect as the legislation passed by the legislature. A similar power has been given to the governors of the state under Article 213 of the Indian Constitution.
Maurya, K., & Sood, S. (2024). A law & economic analysis of 'ordinance raj' in india: Navigating the rule v standard debate in the legal design as a mechanism to reduce political cartelization. GNLU Journal of Law And Economics, VII(I), 94–120. https://doi.org/10.69893/gjle.2024.000064
The Supreme Court ruling in Property Owners Association v. State of Maharashtra (2024) is a decisive institutional recalibration in the history of property...
The implementation of global penalty under the Competition Act, 2002 through the Competition (Amendment) Act, 2023 has raised concerns among competition law...
Mr. Abhyudaya Yadav, Dr. Ankit Shrivastav and Dr. Jasmine Kaur
Evaluating the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) using applied empirical research evaluates whether the stakeholders, such as Resolution Profes...
This decade has witnessed a steep hike in the use of deceptive and manipulative design techniques, broadly referred to as dark patterns. The purpose of such...
Dr. Tilottama Raychaudhuri and Ms. Shatakshi Johri
One of the primary objectives of the norms of corporate governance is to reduce the agency costs between management and shareholders. To this end, the agenc...
The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) was enacted to consolidate and streamline insolvency proceedings in India, aiming for timely resolution and max...