logo
logo
logo
logo
logo
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Advisory Board
    • Editorial Board
    • Abstracting & indexing
    • Copyright & Licensing Information
    • Peer Review Process
  • Volumes
  • Call for Papers
  • Publication Guidelines
  • Contact Us
Cover
6 Downloads
154 Views

Global Penalties, Local Harm: Why Economic Theory Disfavours Global Turnover Based Fines Under India's Competition Law

  • By Mr. Abhyudaya Yadav, Dr. Ankit Shrivastav and Dr. Jasmine Kaur
  • 15 Days ago
Volume IX 2026 Issue I GNLU Journal of Law And Economics
The implementation of global penalty under the Competition Act, 2002 through the Competition (Amendment) Act, 2023 has raised concerns among competition law academics and practitioners. This revision marks a significant departure from the relevant turnover doctrine based on the ruling in Excel Crop Care Ltd. v. CCI, raising concerns over proportionality and economic coherence. The legislative change creates a structural disconnect between an act within a constrained economic context, geographically within India, and the ambit of sanctions imposed globally. This paper challenges this trend by attempting to reconcile global turnover linked sanctions with legal theory and economic tools. This involves deterrence theory, optimal fine determination, proportionality norms, and marginal harm analysis to suggest that global turnover linked penalties may be economically unviable and legally unsustainable. This paper adopts a doctrinal and law and economics methodology, analysing Indian and comparative approaches to global turnover based penalties. The paper contends that the prevailing policy risks chilling innovation and investment, creates tensions with competitive neutrality, and weakens the territorially grounded orientation of the Competition Act, 2002. It argues for a penalty model grounded in harm attribution rather than enterprise size to restore proportionality and regulatory legitimacy.

Tags
Global turnover penalty proportionality optimal fine and marginal harm etc.

Recommended Citation

Abhyudaya Yadav, D. A. S., & Kaur, J. (2026). Global penalties, local harm: Why economic theory disfavours global turnover based fines under india's competition law. GNLU Journal of Law And Economics, IX(I), 154–176. https://doi.org/10.69893/gjle.2026.000090

  • You may also like to read
Cover
Raising the Guardrails on Property Rights: Kesavananda, Minerva Mills, and the 2024 Recalibration of State Power

The Supreme Court ruling in Property Owners Association v. State of Maharashtra (2024) is a decisive institutional recalibration in the history of property...

  • Pratishtha Chaturvedi and Prof. (Dr.) Ram Singh
  • Issue I | Volume IX 2026
Read article
Cover
Evaluating the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP): Empirical Evidence on Operational Issues, Challenges, and Stakeholder Dynamics

Evaluating the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) using applied empirical research evaluates whether the stakeholders, such as Resolution Profes...

  • Dr. Hiteshkumar Thakkar
  • Issue I | Volume IX 2026
Read article
Cover
The Regulation of Dark Patterns by Competition Law: A Cross Jurisdictional Analysis with Insights from Indian Jurisprudence

This decade has witnessed a steep hike in the use of deceptive and manipulative design techniques, broadly referred to as dark patterns. The purpose of such...

  • Dr. Tilottama Raychaudhuri and Ms. Shatakshi Johri
  • Issue I | Volume IX 2026
Read article
Cover
Corporate Governance and the Limits of Legal Regulation: An InDepth Analysis of Executive Compensation at Amara Raja Energy Mobility Ltd.

One of the primary objectives of the norms of corporate governance is to reduce the agency costs between management and shareholders. To this end, the agenc...

  • Dr. Shweta Mohan & Dr. Shantanu Braj Choubey
  • Issue I | Volume IX 2026
Read article
Cover
Conflict Between Homebuyers and Other Creditors in the Real Estate Sector During Insolvency Proceedings: A Law and Economic Analysis

The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) was enacted to consolidate and streamline insolvency proceedings in India, aiming for timely resolution and max...

  • Rajbeer Singh Saluja & Bharadwaja Reddy Chintakunta
  • Issue I | Volume IX 2026
Read article
Cover
Deconstructing Income Inequality: A MultiMetric Analysis of Regional Disparities in India

Despite three decades of sustained economic growth, income inequality across Indian states has widened, with persistent ruralurban disparities. Paper argues...

  • Prof. L.C. Mallaiah, Abhishek Kumar Kushwaha, Asha Prasuna
  • Issue I | Volume IX 2026
Read article
GNLU Journal of Law & Economics  SCOPUS-Indexed. Open-Access Journal. Peer-Reviewed
ISSN 2582-2667 Peer Reviewed Submit Manuscript
GNLU Center for Law and Economics GNLU Center for Law and Economics Gujarat National Law University

GJLE publishes interdisciplinary research at the intersection of law and economics under the aegis of GNLU Centre for Law & Economics (CLE) & GNLU Centre for Empirical & Applied Research in Law & Interdisciplinary Studies (CEARLIS)

Get Connected

Explore

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advisory Board
  • Editorial Board
  • Volumes
  • Announcements
  • Contact Us

For Authors

  • Call for Papers
  • Submissions
  • Publication Guidelines
  • Peer Review Process
  • Abstracting & Indexing
  • Copyright & Licensing
  • Publication Ethics

Contact

Centre for Law & Economics
Gujarat National Law University
Attalika Avenue, Knowledge Corridor, Koba
Gandhinagar - 382426, Gujarat, India
  • +91-79-23276611 / 12
  • gjle@gnlu.ac.in
  • www.gjle.in
Call for Papers

© , All Rights Reserved by GNLU Journal of Law & Economics

Powered by - Adit Microsys