Conflict Between Homebuyers and Other Creditors in the Real Estate Sector During Insolvency Proceedings: A Law and Economic Analysis

The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) was enacted to consolidate and streamline insolvency proceedings in India, aiming for timely resolution and maximisation of asset value. However, its initial framework did not take into account, the unique position of homebuyers in real estate insolvency cases, leaving them without statutory recognition as creditors. This gap often resulted in financial and personal problems for individuals who had invested in underconstruction properties. The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018 addressed this by conferring the status of financial creditors upon homebuyers under Section 5(8)(f), thereby granting them representation in the Committee of Creditors and voting rights in resolution processes. While this reform was a significant step towards consumer protection, practical challenges in its implementation such as coordination among dispersed creditors, high voting thresholds, and prolonged litigation have limited its effectiveness. This paper explores the statutory framework, judicial pronouncements with a special emphasis on the Supertech judgement, and economic analysis to evaluate the current regime. It further proposes reforms to enhance efficiency, ensure equitable treatment, and align the IBCs application in the real estate sector with its core objectives.

ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF PROVIDING SUBSIDIZED PUBLIC TRANSPORT FOR WOMEN WITH REFERENCE TO RAMESH KAMAL V. STATE OF H.P. AND ANR

This case analysis aims to investigate the pros and cons of the Nari Ko Naman scheme launched by the Himachal Pradesh government offering subsidised bus transport to women across the state against which a petition was filed in Ramesh Kamal v. State of H.P (2022). This case studys primary goal will be to critically analyse whether offering subsidised bus transport for women is a case of freebies or if it is a policy that is working towards empowering women and increasing their participation in the economy by incentivising them to pursue education and employment. This case study utilises primary data collected through an online questionnaire and secondary data such as research papers, government reports and news articles. Both qualitative and quantitative data were analysed in the process. This data is critically evaluated by employing various micro and macroeconomic tools, analysing the various features of the scheme brought into question before the court, similar global and Indian practices, and analysing substitutes to the existingscheme.