This decade has witnessed a steep hike in the use of deceptive and manipulative design techniques, broadly referred to as dark patterns. The purpose of such patterns is to play on consumer biases and coax consumers into decisions that they may not have otherwise taken, especially where such decisions entail negative consequences. To address this concern, there has been development of laws which prohibit the usage of dark patterns, including consumer, advertising and data protection laws. However, the jurisprudence in this regard is piecemeal. Dark patterns are an intrinsic feature of digital markets, and competition authorities too are addressing such practices, without calling them out as dark patterns. In this paper the authors conduct a cross jurisdictional examination of laws regulating dark patterns and point out the need for specific competition law regulation of dark patterns in India.
The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) was enacted to consolidate and streamline insolvency proceedings in India, aiming for timely resolution and maximisation of asset value. However, its initial framework did not take into account, the unique position of homebuyers in real estate insolvency cases, leaving them without statutory recognition as creditors. This gap often resulted in financial and personal problems for individuals who had invested in underconstruction properties. The Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018 addressed this by conferring the status of financial creditors upon homebuyers under Section 5(8)(f), thereby granting them representation in the Committee of Creditors and voting rights in resolution processes. While this reform was a significant step towards consumer protection, practical challenges in its implementation such as coordination among dispersed creditors, high voting thresholds, and prolonged litigation have limited its effectiveness. This paper explores the statutory framework, judicial pronouncements with a special emphasis on the Supertech judgement, and economic analysis to evaluate the current regime. It further proposes reforms to enhance efficiency, ensure equitable treatment, and align the IBCs application in the real estate sector with its core objectives.
Despite three decades of sustained economic growth, income inequality across Indian states has widened, with persistent ruralurban disparities. Paper argues that inequality is fundamentally a legal and institutional problem, not merely an economic one. Using a multimetric empirical framework integrating the Gini coefficient, percentile ratios, Generalized Entropy (GE) indices, and the Atkinson index we analyse income inequality across High, Moderate, and Low Net State Domestic Product state groups, identified through Zscore standardisation, supplemented by OLS regression and Theil index decomposition. Moderate NSDP rural areas record the highest inequality (Gini 0.4849; p90/p10 15.656; A(1) 0.394), while High NSDP urban areas exhibit rising topend wealth concentration (GE(1) 0.1969). Financial inclusion emerges as the strongest predictor of reduced inequality ( 0.31, p 0.01). Theil decomposition reveals that 58% of total inequality is intrastate, rendering interstate fiscal transfers insufficient as a standalone remedy. The paper recommends targeted reforms to the Direct Benefit Transfer framework, labour law, agricultural market regulation, and progressive taxation to address India's structural inequality.
This piece was originally written by Prof. (Dr.) Thomas S. Ulen as the foreword to the edited book Economic Analysis of Law and Governance, and is reproduced here as a dedication to Prof. (Dr.) Thomas S. Ulen. This foreword reflects on the reception of law and economics in the Indian legal academy and bar, situating this reception within the discipline's own history in the United States. Drawing on Thomas Kuhn's account of paradigm shifts, Prof. Ulen draws an analogy between the rise of law and economics with the displacement of the geocentric model by the heliocentric one, while cautioning that unlike astronomy, law and economics need not displace doctrinal scholarship but can coexist alongside it. He surveys the discipline's global spread, and the persistence of confirmation bias among scholars and practitioners alike. Finally, he closes with predictions for the future of law and economics in public health law, legal history, comparative law, and above all the growing importance of empirical data in legal scholarship. We are reproducing this Foreword here in honour of Prof. Ulens legacy and his invaluable contributions to the genesis and evolution of Law and Economics at GNLU and other universities in India. We are publishing this foreword along with the lectures delivered by Prof. Ulen during the 03rd GNLU Workshop on Law and Economics: Theories and Applications, organised by the GNLU Centre for Law and Economics in the fall of 2022.
This case analysis aims to investigate the pros and cons of the Nari Ko Naman scheme launched by the Himachal Pradesh government offering subsidised bus transport to women across the state against which a petition was filed in Ramesh Kamal v. State of H.P (2022). This case studys primary goal will be to critically analyse whether offering subsidised bus transport for women is a case of freebies or if it is a policy that is working towards empowering women and increasing their participation in the economy by incentivising them to pursue education and employment. This case study utilises primary data collected through an online questionnaire and secondary data such as research papers, government reports and news articles. Both qualitative and quantitative data were analysed in the process. This data is critically evaluated by employing various micro and macroeconomic tools, analysing the various features of the scheme brought into question before the court, similar global and Indian practices, and analysing substitutes to the existingscheme.
International biodiversity governance has progressively evolved from a predominantly ecological and conservationoriented approach toward a more integrated framework that incorporates economic reasoning. This article argues that such an evolution is not merely terminological, but reflects a deeper transformation in the way biodiversity is conceptualized and governed at the international level. The study examines whether, and to what extent, international biodiversity conventions and related policy initiatives have incorporated economic considerations alongside traditional conservation objectives. Using a text analysis methodology, the article analyzes the language of key international conventions adopted since the 1970s, distinguishing between early conservation agreements, statebased conventions, and instruments developed within the framework of the Convention on Biological Diversity. This analysis is complemented by an examination of the conceptual frameworks adopted by the Intergovernmental SciencePolicy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services and the European Union Biodiversity Strategy. The findings show a growing emphasis on ecosystems, ecosystem services, and human wellbeing, which emerges progressively across the examined instruments and culminates in the KunmingMontreal Global Biodiversity Framework. From a lawandeconomics perspective, this study argues that economic instrumentssuch as taxes, subsidies, tradable permits, and payments for ecosystem servicesplay a crucial role in translating biodiversity commitments into effective and actionable policy measures. The article concludes that future biodiversity governance is likely to rely increasingly on economic approaches to complement legal obligations and enhance their practical effectiveness.
The article examines the intersection of labour issues with antitrust law, highlighting a shift fromtraditional consumerfocused perspectives. Historically, antitrust authorities have approachedissues from the vantage of consumer protection, labour law, and human rights, often overlookingthe antitrust implications of labour practices. Recently, however, there has been increased scrutinyon nonpoach and noncompete agreements, with competition authorities drawing analogiesbetween the labour market and retail markets, where workers are seen as products and companiesas colluding entities.This article advances the discussion by exploring a novel antitrust concern within the labourmarket. By analyzing recent controversies involving Dior and Armani, accused of exploitingworkers through inhumane conditions and low wages, the authors argue that labour costs, anintegral component of production costs, should also be examined under antitrust frameworks.Specifically, they propose that extremely low labour costs, which can significantly reduceproduction costs, should be scrutinized as a form of predatory pricing.The authors suggest that current antitrust laws, which do not typically address such labourpractices, should evolve to incorporate new tools to address these challenges. They drawcomparisons with European antitrust approaches to propose potential solutions for integratinglabour market concerns into traditional antitrust analyses.
Child marriage across India has shown a declining tendency, however, the State of Bihar continues to exhibit this harmful practice at a staggering high percentage. It is considered as an economic solution to deal with the financial burden attached with the upbringing of a girlchild. The author has used economic analysis of law to examine the efficacy and efficiency of the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, in the state of Bihar. The study is based on secondary data available from National Family Health Survey4 and NFHS5, Census of India and Economic survey of Bihar. The use of descriptive and exploratory studies helped the author in yielding stimulative insights into the relationship between individual behaviour and social practices. Based on scientific and logical understanding, the study proves that a society would always prefer to choose, exercise and continue solemnising child marriage practices if the benefits (economic, social and psychological) of child marriage is higher than the opportunity cost of getting arrested and convicted under the law. The social benefits associated with child marriage for the poor, populous, patriarchal society like Bihar outweighs the social cost linked to the prohibition law.
I address many themes constituting difficult terrains and am fully aware of problems of stricttime limits and temptation to evils of obfuscation and bouts of ostentatious learning that besetscholarly addresses.
Defection is not an unfamiliar term for parliamentary democracies like India. Though the evilpractice was present since the preindependence era, the advent of the multiparty systemresulting in coalition governments increased floor crossing.
Economists have studied the psychology of crime and how individuals react to changes in theeconomy. One basic idea is laws are enacted to lower down crime rates and discouragepotential offenders from committing crimes.